Eating Disorders and Romance

Author
Publication year
2022
Pages
136-149
Comment

The Introduction states that in this essay "Ellen Carter looks at an aspect of mental health representation."

---

Eating disorders (EDs) and body image concerns are cultural and societal issues of growing contemporary significance. [...] In this essay I compare real world data on EDs with fictional depictions and argue that these novels perpetuate inaccurate cultural norms about "good" EDs and patients, as well as portraying a rosier-than-reality impact on long-term mental and physical health. In other words, just as the romance genre idealizes intimate relationships, these novels idealize EDs.

Corpus and Methodology

I analyzed twenty-one contemporary romance novels or series published between 2001 and 2019, each of which has a main character with an ED. (136)

---

ED prevalence in my corpus does not match the pattern found in real populations, with anorexia over-represented. (137)

---

Within my corpus of twenty-one novels, twelve open with the character in recovery, eight are in denial, and in only one book does the ED begin during the narrative. (140)

---

I've not added tags for all the authors in Carter's corpus, just for the ones where there was somewhat lengthier (albeit still pretty short) discussion of their book and/or the author.