Individuation and the Romance Novel

Degree
PhD thesis
University
Pacifica Graduate Institute
Publication year
2022
Comment

There is an epigraph which quotes from "Fancy Pants, Elizabeth Phillips [sic]", but there is little engagement with modern popular romances as primary sources: the text studied in most detail is Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. However, a romance written by the author is included and comprises the second half of the document. There is also little engagement with romance scholarship, with the focus instead on psychology and the history of novels and reading. Here's the abstract:

This dissertation explores how romance novels present the love encountered in romantic relationships as a catalyst towards individuation. Throughout history women in patriarchal societies have sustained an unconscious wounding to their psyches through the subjugation of their reading and writing, as well as their historical position as second- class citizens. Women rebelled by writing romance novels which women readers gobbled up. These novels have from the beginning provided a safe space to explore issues affecting women and marginalized others. Romance novels, modern day retellings of important myths and fairytales about love relationships, reveal not only the deep human longing for relationship but also how relationships can be a catalyst towards individuation. They are empowering stories that provide not only escapism and vicarious happiness, but enable readers to identify with both protagonists, thus encouraging an integration of feminine and masculine energies, the creation of a holistic androgynous self. A close reading of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice show how working through their initial opposition allows Elizabeth and Darcy to forge a resilient relationship that supports their individual individuation journeys.
The production component of this dissertation is a historical romance novel, Silk Dagger, which follows the heroine and hero, Frankie and Sebastian, as they navigate treacherous waters at sea and within their relationship. While to begin with they are at odds with each other and with themselves, they unite to vanquish a common threat to their families. Through their encounters, they are called upon to see in themselves and in the other the qualities each needs to not only survive, but to become whole.

----

This dissertation uses the lens of depth psychology to examine how the romance novel presents the love encountered in romantic relationships as a catalyst towards individuation; the integration of the feminine and masculine energies within oneself. I surmise that encountering empowered characters on the page not only brings joy, escapism, and a safe space to explore issues affecting women and marginalized others, but enables readers to identify with both protagonists, integrating feminine and masculine energies leading to the androgynous Self.
This study will also explore how love is at the heart of romance novels. (12)

---

Mythic stories about couples in love embody crucial moral imperatives that are essential to a successful pair bonding, assisting in the survival of the species. I will explore myths about love and couples in love and its necessity in the individuation process. I’ll look at Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, which will function as an example of how the individuation process is presented within a work of literature. (13)

---